A large blue fabric symbolizing the lake where the fish swim
Laminated paper fish (with numbers on their bodies and paper clips attached at their mouths)
One magnetic fishing rod per team (made from a mop handle or stick, with a string hanging down and a strong magnet attached to the end)
If playing outdoors, a small inflatable kiddie pool filled with water can be used, and the fish can be made from wooden boards, so they float on the water surface
Dice (e.g., made of foam and larger than usual), two per team – if needed